Character is Fate ...Truth and Consequences

Careless people smash up things and then retreat back into their
vast carelessness and let other people clean up the mess they’ve made….
― F. Scott Fitzgerald

Medieval Manuscript

Leonard Brice was always right which was another way of saying he was never wrong.

This fact irritated his colleagues, annoyed his wife and angered his friends—No, wait, make that alienated his friends.

An unfortunate incident at lunch that very afternoon resulted in the fact that, Leonard Brice, Professor Emeritus and Doctor of Medieval Studies, now had no friends.

Frederick Hassan, the last holdout in Leonard’s dwindling circle of friends, had finally had enough. He confronted Leonard while at lunch in the university-dining hall.

Everyone stopped eating to stare at them.

“Thomas Hardy did not say, character is fate,” Frederick stormed (a very undignified behaviour for a Professor of Literature) “it was Novalis.”

“Are you very certain of that, Professor Hassan?” Leonard peered over his glasses in that patronizing way that drove women mad and men crazy.

“Of course, I’m certain—what do you take me for—an idiot?”

Leonard considered the possibility while nibbling on a wedge of Melba toast.

Alfred Burbage hesitated and then cleared his throat before venturing, “Actually, to tell the truth, Frederick, Hardy did make the statement in The Mayor of Casterbridge—so, technically, Leonard is right.”

This pronouncement came as a sentence of death. The room went very still.

With great restraint, Professor Hassan, or Freddie, as the girls at the Follies called him, rose to his feet, trembling with rage and managed a polite, “Good day, gentlemen,” before storming out of the hall.

“I do hope I didn’t offend him,” Leonard said to the others at the table. Professor Wilcox’s jaw was working, but he refrained from commenting.

Leonard decided to work late that evening. He telephoned Beatrice and told her not to wait dinner and he’d be home around ten.

She sounded more relieved than disappointed.

“Oh, by the way, Leonard, that archeologist—Toller Franz called asking if you had determined a date for that artifact.”

“That dolt—I told him I would notify him when I completed my assessment."

Another nuisance to dispose of, Leonard grimaced. This Franz character was convinced he had found a lost work of Chaucer’s—The Tale of Chanticleer.

How absurd.

Although he was ninety percent certain the text was just another medieval forgery, he still felt compelled to do a proper analysis to verify his suspicions.

He had sent a fragment of the scroll to be carbon dated and requested the ink be analyzed as well. Possessing an original autograph by Chaucer would be well nigh impossible—but still, until he received the test results, he could not rule anything out
.
Sitting down at his desk, he rifled through his inbox in search of the envelope containing the test results. He found it and tore it open. His blood froze.

The date was compatible with Middle English authorship and the ink had been assigned a similar time period as well.

He was wrong. For the first time in his career, the first time in his entire professional life, Professor Brice was wrong.

He read and reread the paper to no avail—it was irrefragable proof—he was wrong.

He could see the smug expressions of his colleagues, particularly Frederick Hassan’s exotic features, wreathed in smiles of beatific joy.

The Master had fallen. He was fallible at last—accountable like the rest of them—smelling of mortality…and flesh.

He knew it could not be. In that instant, he took his life in his hands, deciding to become master of his fate—captain of his soul.

He placed the manuscript and the paper bearing the lab results on his worktable and toppled an amber glass container.

He watched as the watery liquid spread across the desk, sizzling and smoking and consuming the documents in the blink of an eye.

An unfortunate accident had occurred, he’d explain later—a vial of caustic soda used to clean implements had spilled and written artifacts had been destroyed.

Since he alone requested the results, there’d be no record of the lab findings and no way to ascertain the worth of the documents.

He sat back in his chair and smiled. It was over. His weakness, finally uncovered, would remain undiscovered by the world at large.

Mind you, the world at large would be denied access to an original and irreplaceable Chaucer masterpiece. It was an unfortunate but unavoidable consequence.

He phoned Beatrice.

“Frederick Hassan is dead,” she whispered.

“Dead—how?”

“Committed suicide this afternoon—jumped off the Rosedale Valley Bridge.”

“How unfortunate,” Leonard replied hoarsely.

“Yes,” she agreed.

“Well, try not to let it upset you, Leonard. I kept your dinner warm. You must have had an exhausting day preserving those priceless manuscripts for posterity.”

Leonard didn't hear his wife's words—the phone had fallen to the floor.

For the first time in his flawed mind, he saw the consequences of his own pride.

© 2025, John J Geddes. All rights reserved

Photo