RE: Tier Five Guild Brawls and Should We Add Human Only Wild?

I don't think it would pass a vote due to the fact that you're going to have to split the rewards somehow... which means you either need to split existing modern/wild into thirds... or you need to split wild rewards for passive/active play. The question at that point becomes... why do we need passive play at all when an airdrop would suffice? Which also raises the other obvious logical fallacy here... we don't have a "human only" modern... which means we likely wouldn't have a "human only" wild. There just isn't enough match liquidity to support it.

I think a better approach would be this...

• Have sylar or the archmage guys bring the bot internal.
• Have the "passive players" that want to stake cards and not actually play lock their cards into the in-game bot system.
• Use the in-game bot system to generate match liquidity with real assets.
• Split rewards into thirds for modern/wild/passive.
• Solves the match liquidity, solves the "passive" play, gives the same "human only" situation you have in modern right now... but with the requirement of actual owned assets being used to provide the match liquidity.
• Obvious problem is this would take development time and require passing a proposal that I doubt would get strong support due to the aforementioned reward split.

Anyways, that's how I would personally approach all of this, but yea, I'd suggest following azircon's advice to see if you can at least get the majority of top holders to accept or at least not block the idea before spending too much time on it.